BodyBackground

News

Current Articles | Archives | Search

Designers are generalists who need to consult specialists. For Don Norman, one of the foremost design thinkers, this is the future of our domain. On November 9th, he held a Lecture at the Design Academy Eindhoven through the format of an open discussion. His main goal was to address the changing role of design, the dialogue it shares with art, and how both are implemented in education. 

The afternoon began with a short presentation of the Boijmans Van Beuningen Museum’s Nieuwe Energie (New Energy) exhibition by one if its chief curators. As the backdrop to the subsequent open-mic debate held by Norman, this pitch talked about the changing role of design not only in contextual form but also in terms of production, sustainability, and user centricity. This current exhibition shows the slow shift from design purely for the discussion of design to a new social focus. The examples this curator presented arguably did not manage to make that shift strong enough and truly remained in flat one-liner so called poetic value. Aesthetics seems to return to the now dogmatic notions of material experimentation and anecdotal gimmicky transformations of everyday ‘mundane’ objects.

The potential for the slow shift into deeper manipulations cannot rely on quick cutesy references. One example, Dunne and Raby’s post-nihilistic 1980’s adapted utopias where highways are reclaimed by nature, pushes the bar the most. Chandeliers built from small randomly placed solar panels formed as butterflies does little aesthetically to communicate its message, be it didactic or not, let alone reflect the substance of ‘new energy.’ Designer are certainly becoming extreme in trying to get their points across, like in Mike Thompson’s Blood Lamp, where the user needs to drop blood to gain light, the statement is undoubtedly of personified technology. The curator did ask an important question, “do we change to suit the world or does the world change to suit us?”

Don Norman began his introduction in a perhaps theatrical manner, walking through the audience, to the back of the room, and seeing how he could turn the lights on. He subsequently asked the question, “Is this space designed?” Highlighting the problem of this space’s efficiency, he went on to raise the issue of our education at this academy. Before Anne Mieke Eggenkamp, the school’s chairwoman joined the debate, he prefaced by looking into the difference of art and design. The provocative nature of art is not relevant in design as simple objects work best. Alluding back to the previous exhibition presentation, he questioned weather or not some of the work could just simply be called conceptual art, as it would still convey the same message. “You don’t solve problems with smart technology on a personal level.”

The Design Academy Eindhoven has always been known for its more artistic approach to design but is that still viable in this domain’s changing climate? The change towards service, life changing, design can only occur in the day-to-day education. He resolved by saying, “nobody can teach design.” In such an institution where the ‘artists’ sole is in their hands,’ how can the balance of essentials be taught in four years? What are the essentials? This question provides a good challenge to the academy’s everything goes policy. Norman mentioned ‘classical training’ that referred to drawing, modeling, rendering, and a studio class format with much less materiality. Norman is in favor of facilitation rather then being taught and studio classes; designers are the worse judges of their own work. Eggenkamp asked the students weather or not they need more lectures. An initial response of wanting to only work by hand was quickly refuted with a claim that we are too introspective by doing so. This returned to something Norman said earlier, “The program needs to kick us out into the world or bring the world in.”

He concluded the discussion by bringing his performative exercise to a close. If I would teach I would give an assignment, bringing it home, it would be multipurpose, spatial, empathetic, all players considered, the viewer, user, technical, and structural. He was referring to the re-design of the Witte Dame Zaal, the space in which this debate was held.  A student stood up and offered his skills to Eggenkamp in doing so. Norman replied, “It will require a multi-disciplinary team. The question remains, how do we learn how to operate in such collaborations, what skills can we learn and be taught in this new method?
 

  • Conversation: Don Norman, Anne Mieke Eggenkamp
  • Report by Adrian Madler, student Design Academy
  • Projectmanagement, copy-editor eindredactie Danielle Arets
Author: DAEnews
Published: 01-Dec-2011 12:34

Categories

Official News
  • Design is Applied Social Science

    Don Norman

DAEnews tweets

TweetId: 512467087160520704 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews DAE alumni dominate the nominees for the prestigious New Material Award, a € 15,000 prize for innovation & creativity http://t.co/ob3eGCUEes 18-09-14 05:04
TweetId: 512219406597107712 DesignAcademyE'hoven retweeted Fontanel Magazine fontanel fontanel Vandaag presenteren we wederom een @DAEnews alumni als Fontanel Finals Young Talent 2014: Martina Lasinger. — http://t.co/Ta0JXnsSGT 17-09-14 12:39
TweetId: 512219210924429312 DesignAcademyE'hoven retweeted capada Daniellearets Daniellearets Nice start design research space on 2.5 d printing with @guidostompff @Karianne__Rygh @crispnl @DAEnews http://t.co/GYK8wjnkeM 17-09-14 12:39
TweetId: 512219133409517568 DesignAcademyE'hoven retweeted capada Daniellearets Daniellearets Today @Designdebates we will discuss the future of design education with @DAEnews @tudelft @SintLucas; 17-09-14 12:38
TweetId: 512218730336493569 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews DAE exhibition Self/Unself opened to great acclaim last Saturday - further strengthening our cultural ties with China.http://t.co/EedrxifLQs 17-09-14 12:37
TweetId: 512218730336493569 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews DAE exhibition Self/Unself opened to great acclaim last Saturday - further strengthening our cultural ties with China.http://t.co/EedrxifLQs 17-09-14 12:37
TweetId: 512189119175614464 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews @janboelen brings a critical eye to curating http://t.co/kSNzuGzJPT with many DAE participants. Not just design & society but design & life. 17-09-14 10:39
TweetId: 511846442798174208 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews @DAEnews alumni @StudioJobPR talks to @newyorktimes re his collection of curated objects for Chamber Boutique in NYNY http://t.co/v4curUtzUy 16-09-14 11:57
TweetId: 511800437885112320 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews "The Dutch are back in New York" says @newyorktimes claiming funding cuts forced designers to find new markets. http://t.co/Y6d7oWjf4v 16-09-14 08:55
TweetId: 511789719345463296 DesignAcademyE DAEnews DAEnews Self Unself just opened in Suzhou. A gorgeous show & an enthusiastic audience. Lots of pics up at our Instagram site: http://t.co/yhsj1jnnqx 16-09-14 08:12