Current Articles | Archives | Search

A meeting with MA students of TU Delft, 17 January - by Diogo Rinaldi

The 2nd year students of the Design Academy’s master programmes joined the Delft University of Technology (TU Delft) Industrial Design master students for a debate on the role of designers in society. Professor of form theory, Paul Hekkert, and Marieke Sonneveld, assistant professor of industrial design, welcomed the group at the impressive building of the Industrial Design department. In their welcoming talk they raised the impression that when we try to define ‘what' an industrial designer is, we come back with a lot of polarized answers between the two different ‘flavours’ of design.

Mark Henning, from the Social Design department, opened the discussion with a brief explanation of how the master program is organized at DAE, highlighting the broad range of different disciplines of the master student’s backgrounds. “They tend to accumulate professional experience before arriving at DAE,” he said. He stressed that the research is done through design, not through theory. Paul Hekkert followed with a presentation on how the Industrial Designer at Delft is commonly perceived, with a mindset that revolves around a triangle between business, technology, and people, and a firm base on previously validated methodology.

The two student groups were then divided into small groups of four with students from both institutions to debate one of the two propositions that were presented to them:
1. Designers should guide people to do the right thing. (posed by Paul Hekkert.)
2. Considering our contemporary condition of products and information overload, the truly responsible designer is one who designs nothing at all.  (posed by DAE’s Alice Twemlow.)

After that, everybody was rounded back in the amphitheater to share the comments. The discussion started with trying to understand what 'right' meant in the first proposition. ‘Right’ can mean different things to different people. DAE students commonly shared a perception that they only know what is right for themselves, and that their designs should evoke this personification. Delft students, on the other hand, see themselves as mirrors that understand and translate the necessities of the stakeholders into a new meaning. Important arguments were raised from both sides, intensifying the distinction between the two institutions. Local students questioned the freedom DAE students have, both in terms of topics of interest and processes, in contrast to the TU’s organization, methodology-bound and rigorously validated structure. At one point, someone even questioned if the students from the different institutions were actually 'two different species of designers'. That statement led to intentions of finding a middle ground where both contrasting opinions would meet: perhaps in curriculum related projects, or within the realm of personal projects. Beers and snacks at the end eased the mix and helped to ignite possible futures.

Published: 31-Jan-2017 09:49


Home News
  • Polarized reflections and shared intentions

  • Polarized reflections and shared intentions

Photography: Sebastian Lilge

DAEnews tweets

TweetId: 898079449006182400 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews Court Dance from #DAEalumnus Dorota Gazy is nominated for the European Youth Award 2017! #Congratulations >… 17-08-17 07:10
TweetId: 897740582617010176 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews When science and art become one.. 16-08-17 08:43
TweetId: 897411364460867584 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews Marie Caye and Arvid Jense created SAM, the Symbiotic Autonomous Machine that even has is own bank account > 15-08-17 10:55
TweetId: 886869303647252480 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews We are delighted and proud to announce the nominees for the Gijs Bakker, René Smeets and Melkweg Awards #DAEstudents 17-07-17 08:44
TweetId: 869176316075159553 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews @xandraschutte Hi i heard you at WDCD & wanted to ask you for a jury 4 design academy. can you email me pls thanks 29-05-17 12:59
TweetId: 867413759962345477 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews Bruce Mao ends #wdcd2017 with a modest admission: "I want to live in a world where I can have a coke, but not pass the cheque onto my kids." 24-05-17 16:15
TweetId: 867408069965352962 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews Bruce Mao asks “Do designers protest, protect or produce?” @ #wdcd2017 & self-replies that it's all connected to individual capacity. 24-05-17 15:52
TweetId: 867405558734884864 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews "Tradition is innovation that works," says Rodrigo Oliveira of restaurannt Mocotó in São Paulo @ #wdc2017- for rich,poor, famous & ordinary. 24-05-17 15:42
TweetId: 867386407307923456 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews Naresh Ramchandani says rising sea levels, climate migrants, floods & extinctions worsen so people can live the way they want to @ #wdcd2017 24-05-17 14:26
TweetId: 867050031500726272 DesignAcademyE'hoven DAEnews DAEnews Nice first day of discussions, ideas, hopes, problems & dreams at #wdcd2017 Great reminder about the power of design to pave the way forward 23-05-17 16:10